Case Studies

IBM
Building

Basingstoke

THE PROPERTY

A distressed asset acquired for £3.25m, with the tenant’s stated intention to phase out their occupation during the 3.5 years remaining on their lease.

THE STRATEGY

We negotiated an early surrender with the tenant for a premium, plus a £2.56m cash settlement in lieu of dilapidations. This combined total saw us return 80% of equity even before any sale had occurred.

THE OUTCOME

Despite achieving permitted development approval and significant GDV projections, we were aware of potential issues and therefore opted to sell to developer to provide deal certainty and optimise higher IRR. We sold for £5.4m after only 3.5 years. Ultimately, the developer encountered challenges that caused a 5 year setback, further highlighting the benefit of our decision to sell pre-development.

BOUGHT £3.25m

DISTRIBUTED£2.56m

SOLD£5.4m

TIMEFRAME 3.5 years

Convatec
Laboratories

Rhymney, South Wales

THE PROPERTY

A single-let building where the tenant applied to us for permission to carry out extensive alterations to meet their requirements.

THE STRATEGY

  • Negotiate a rent increase at the rent review.
  • Inform them of our intention to sell which will naturally trigger a concern that a new landlord may not agree to alterations.
  • Offer them a ‘first refusal’ on the purchase.

THE OUTCOME

We successfully increased the rent by 23% at review and subsequently negotiated a sale of the property at significantly above market value, which gave them unfettered control of their needs. Sale price equated to 2.5 times the original purchase price over a 3-year hold.

SOLD2.5x
Purchase
Price

TIMEFRAME 3 years

Lloyds Bank

Haywards Heath

THE PROPERTY

Acquired as a distressed asset from a lender for £3.5m, on lease to Lloyds Bank, with less than one year remaining until the tenant’s break option.

THE STRATEGY

Our intensive due diligence prior to purchase gave us sufficient comfort to believe Lloyd’s would not exercise their break option.

THE OUTCOME

Indeed, the tenant did not exercise its break option and the asset ultimately sold for £6.35m, generating a 81% profit over 16 months.

PROFIT 81%

TIMEFRAME 16 months

Forest Shopping
Centre

Bordon

THE PROPERTY

We acquired a neighborhood shopping centre (27 tenants) for £4.5m.

THE STRATEGY

After carrying out numerous asset management activities, we sold the asset after 3 years for £7.5m, whilst strategically retaining some land as part of the sale agreement.

THE OUTCOME

After obtaining a pre-let agreement to a large national occupier, we subsequently developed the retained land into a large retail unit plus 12 residential units with 100% debt funding for construction costs.

BOUGHT£4.5m

SOLD £7.5m

TIMEFRAME 3 years

Judd House

Barking, London

THE PROPERTY

The tenant vacated but still had in excess of 60 years remaining on the lease. We entered into surrender negotiations, but the tenant kept stalling.

THE STRATEGY

We served an Interim Schedule of Dilapidations on the tenant to bring them to the table on our terms. As a result, the momentum shifted, with the tenant taking the surrender negotiations seriously.

THE OUTCOME

We successfully negotiated a significant surrender payment and, ultimately, obtained vacant possession. Subsequently, we achieved a sale, at 55% above our pre-Covid valuation, at the height of Covid in addition to the significant surrender premium.

SOLD 55% above valuation

TIMEFRAMEHeight of Covid

Brunel House

Yeovil

THE PROPERTY

This asset, forming part of a £23m portfolio, had only one tenant remaining, with the rest of the building vacant, with very little prospects for further use as offices due to the changing nature of the market.

THE STRATEGY

We strategised on a sale of the property but required vacant possession to do so. Logically the tenant should have demanded a reverse surrender payment from us to deliver VP. Despite this, we negotiated a surrender payment from them, amounting to all their lease obligations until lease expiry (2 years), plus a further sum in consideration of dilapidations.

THE OUTCOME

Further to securing vacant possession, we sold the property at 20% above market value.

SOLD AT HIGHER THAN MARKET VALUE

Supercook

Sherbern-In-Elmert

THE PROPERTY

Purchased for £6.1m with the benefit of a 25-year lease to a multinational tenant at a rent of £495k p.a.

THE STRATEGY

After several years, the tenant discontinued UK operations and stripped all the assets out of their UK corporate arm, leaving us with an effectively dormant tenant company. They then offered us a surrender premium of just £600k. Due to our weakened position, we were advised by a national agent to settle at £1.2m (2 years rent).

THE OUTCOME

A combination of undertaking extensive due diligence on the tenant and nine months of intensive and strategic negotiations resulted in us successfully obtaining a £5.6m surrender premium.

£5.6M (92% of PP) SURRENDER PREMIUM

Churchill Insurance

Teeside Business Park

THE PROPERTY

As part of a £20m office portfolio, this unit was let to a large institutional insurance company, with a passing rent of £450k and a lease expiry imminent.

THE STRATEGY

The tenant sought a lease renewal on very flexible terms at £360k p.a. Our opinion was that the rent should be in the region of c.£470k, on more commercially acceptable terms. No agreement was reached and the tenant appointed a third party expert witness, expecting us to capitulate. We threatened to go to court, confident in our position.

THE OUTCOME

Just before the court date we reached an out-of-court agreement with the tenant for a 15-year lease (break options every 5 years) at £465k p.a.

OUT OF COURT SETTLEMENT REACHED IN OUR FAVOUR

C-Tech

Capenhurst
Technology Park

THE PROPERTY

This asset, forming part of a £32m portfolio, was let to a significant sized tenant who, despite being very happy on site, gave notice that they had to vacate due to their expansion requirements.

THE STRATEGY

We undertook a feasibility study to ascertain the viability of extending their premises to accommodate the tenant’s expansion requirements. We then shared the Study with the tenant an the obvious advantages of remaining on site and they were very happy with the concept.

THE OUTCOME

After obtaining 100% funding for construction work, we created a new, longer, overriding lease on the entire, enlarged premises (old and new), substantially increasing income and capital value.

OBTAINED 100% DEVELOPMENT FUNDING AND NEW OVERRIDING LEASE

BSS / Howdens Unit

Filton, Bristol

THE PROPERTY

Tenant had vacated the building with a few years left on the lease.

THE STRATEGY

We negotiated and obtained a significant surrender premium and dilapidations settlement.

THE OUTCOME

The property was simultaneously let to a new tenant (Howden Joinery) on a new 15-year FRI lease. With the benefit of this new lease, we sold the asset at a significant profit.

PREMIUM & NEW LETTING ACHIEVED
SIMULTANEOUS SURRENDER

Teleperformance

Airdrie

THE PROPERTY

The tenant, on a long lease, employed 1400 people on site but struggled to meet their staff parking needs as their business expanded, which put the long-term viability of their occupation at risk.

THE STRATEGY

  • Acquired the adjacent land and converted it into a fully paved car park, financed with 50% government grant and 50% bank debt.
  • Leased the car park back to the tenant on a co-terminous lease, achieving a double-digit yield on the c.£400k cost (no cash equity required).
  • Achieved a 19% rent increase on main premises through strategic negotiations directly with the CEO.
  • Towards the end of the lease, obtained a substantial surrender premium for an early exit.

THE OUTCOME

We subsequently achieved an above market value sale of the asset by strategically approaching neighboring developers and making the case for the scaled benefits of adjoining the two plots to create a larger development.

RECOGNISING AND CAPITALISING ON HIDDEN VALUE-ADD OPPORTUNITIES

Local Authority
Offices

Oldham

THE PROPERTY

The tenant (Local Council) exercised its break option and vacated the property.

THE STRATEGY

We identified a very minor and technical breach in the tenant’s exercising of the break clause. Despite legal advice predicting slim chances of success, we pursued the issue and strategically offered a compromised settlement as an alternative to issuing court proceedings.

THE OUTCOME

Ultimately, we achieved 65% of the remaining rent liability (until end of lease) and 100% of the dilapidations claim.

SUBSTANTIAL OUT-OF-COURT SETTLEMENT ACHIEVED

Chowley Oak
Business Park

Cheshire

THE PROPERTY

A third-party tenant instructed us to assist with a c. £200K dilapidations claim they had been served by their landlord after vacating a large office premises in Cheshire. Our client had already resigned to paying the claim in full as they had already tried, unsuccessfully, to agree a lower amount, before they were referred to us.

THE STRATEGY

Our in-house surveyor undertook defending the claim, carried out extensive site investigations, reviewed photographic & video evidence and inventories, and negotiated a reduced dilapidations sum.

THE OUTCOME

We negotiated a reduced dilapidation settlement of only £70k, a 65% reduction.

SUCCESSFUL DEFENSE OF LARGE
DILAPIDATIONS CLAIM

Ascensos

Motherwell

THE PROPERTY

A single-let office building with a rent review due in July ’20.

THE STRATEGY

Utilizing relationships with the tenant’s top management and a strategic approach, we negotiated a rent increase despite the lack of material evidence and at the height of COVID.

THE OUTCOME

We obtained a 15% increase at the rent review, during Covid, despite not having any justifiable evidence.

ACHIEVED A RENT INCREASE DESPITE DIFFICULT MARKET CONDITIONS

Baxter Laboratories

Wavertree, Liverpool

THE PROPERTY

An office building let to a significant tenant, with a rent review due in 18 months time.

THE STRATEGY

Despite the rent review not being imminent, our client instructed us to attempt to commence rent review negotiations.

THE OUTCOME

Despite the fact that 18 months still remained on the lease, we negotiated a 10 year renewal (break option after 5) at an increased rent during the height of Covid, far exceeding our client’s expectations.

EXCEEDED CLIENT’S ASPIRATIONS IN NEGOTIATING A LEASE RENEWAL

Queen Street Shopping Centre

Darlington

THE PROPERTY

During the summer of 2020, in the midst of COVID -19, we were instructed to take over as both the property and asset managers for a tired and neglected indoor shopping centre, tenanted by a number of large, historical tenants who were approaching the end of their leases.

THE STRATEGY

Our analysis of the local retail area led us to believe that the only way to keep the centre viable and future proof was to transform the tenant range and attract local independent traders that would add to the diversity and range of the retail offering. Some strategic localised refurbishment was also planned for and implemented.

THE OUTCOME

Over the subsequent 18 months, we strived to prevent the vacancy rate from rising any further, which would have increased landlord void costs, by agreeing new leases at more realistic, market rent levels.

Several years on from instruction, in a retail market that is nationally in a downturn, we have reduced the vacancy rate by over 70%, with currently only 13% vacant. Meanwhile, the rent roll has climbed by 41% during the same period, to £475k p.a., now rebased at realistic sustainable rent levels for even small/local tenants.

REINVIGORATED A TIRED SHOPPING CENTRE